A decision brief under uncertainty
Synthesize competing priorities into a nuanced recommendation.
Name: ____________________ Date: ______________
1. Explore the model
2. Notice and understand
Map the competing priorities: flexibility, feedback, participation and evidence. Identify which claims are known from the brief and which would require further investigation.
3. Practise
Revise: “Self-paced learning will be more effective because everyone prefers flexibility.” Offer a conditional recommendation and name evidence that could change it.
4. Make it your own
Write a 280–320 word decision brief for a training director: recommendation, rationale, strongest counterargument, mitigation within the chosen format and review criteria. Do not invent outcome data or assume funding for both formats.
5. Check your progress
I can weigh competing priorities. I can recommend action while making assumptions and evidence gaps visible.
Mark each goal: not yet / with help / independently. Write one thing to practise next.
Answer key & teaching notes
A defensible response could recommend self-paced delivery if scheduling is the main barrier, with structured self-check tasks and later review of completion and assessment evidence. Live delivery is also defensible if feedback is prioritised. Evaluate reasoning, feasibility and explicit uncertainty.
Support: create an evidence / assumption table. Stretch: write a 75-word executive summary that preserves the central caveat.
For open tasks, check completion, clarity, appropriate language and progress towards the goal. Model answers are examples; other well-supported answers are welcome.