← Back to ELT resources ·

MOHAMED KASSID · STUDENT RESOURCE
ELT · C1 · Older teens 16+ & adults · 45 minutes

Whose voice shapes the story?

Analyse framing, agency and the effect of language choices.

Name: ____________________   Date: ______________

1. Explore the model

Headline A: “Residents challenge redevelopment plan.” Headline B: “Redevelopment delayed by local objections.” Both refer to a proposal to replace an old market with shops and flats. No construction has begun; a public consultation is open.

2. Notice and understand

Compare what each headline places first, who appears as an actor, and what assumptions “delayed” might invite. Distinguish what the short brief states from what readers might infer.

3. Practise

Rewrite Headline B in two ways: one that foregrounds the residents and one that foregrounds the consultation, while preserving the facts.

4. Make it your own

Write a 200–230 word commentary comparing the headlines. Refer to specific wording, offer a plausible alternative interpretation, and finish with a neutral headline. Discuss how your own assumptions affect your reading.

5. Check your progress

I can explain framing using textual evidence. I can distinguish interpretation from established fact.

Mark each goal: not yet / with help / independently. Write one thing to practise next.

Answer key & teaching notes

Possible versions: “Residents raise concerns about redevelopment proposal”; “Consultation opens on market redevelopment proposal.” Neither should imply that construction has started. Other defensible versions are valid.

Support: annotate subject, verb and omitted information. Stretch: explore how nominalisation changes perceived responsibility.

For open tasks, check completion, clarity, appropriate language and progress towards the goal. Model answers are examples; other well-supported answers are welcome.

Original practice material prepared for this resource library. Suggested CEFR levels and ages are guidance, not placement results. Use independently, with a partner or with a teacher. To save offline, use your browser’s Save page option. For a PDF, select Print / save as PDF.