← Back to ELT resources ·

MOHAMED KASSID · STUDENT RESOURCE
ELT · B2 · Teens 14+ & adults · 40 minutes

Should phones have a place in class?

Develop a balanced argument and respond constructively to disagreement.

Name: ____________________   Date: ______________

Before you begin

Think of one time a phone helped you learn and one time it distracted you. You can work alone: say your ideas aloud, then write a few notes.

Useful vocabulary

1. Explore the model

A school proposes keeping phones in bags except during teacher-directed tasks. Supporters say this protects attention. Critics argue that phones can support research and accessibility. Some learners need devices for translation or assistive tools.

Imagine a history lesson. One group uses a phone to check the date of an event, while another learner checks messages and misses the instructions. The same device can support learning or interrupt it, depending on how it is used.

A possible solution is to allow phones for a clear learning purpose and then put them away. Learners who rely on assistive tools may need different arrangements. A short trial could help the school decide whether this rule works in practice.

2. Notice and understand

List two possible benefits and two concerns. Separate the proposed general rule from reasonable access arrangements. What evidence would help evaluate a trial?

Check your reading

Benefits: quick research and access to learning tools. Concerns: distraction and missed instructions. The general rule is to keep phones in bags unless needed for a teacher-directed task; access arrangements allow learners to use tools they need. Evidence could include observations of on-task behaviour and learner feedback before and during a trial.

Language to build your argument

3. Practise

Improve these claims: 1. “Phones always ruin learning.” 2. “Everyone needs a phone.” Replace absolute language with careful qualifiers.

4. Make it your own

Prepare a two-minute proposal with a clear position, one concession and a practical safeguard. Discuss it, then write a 160–190 word recommendation including how you would review the policy after a trial.

Plan before writing: note your position, a benefit, an opposing concern, your safeguard and how you would evaluate the trial. Use these notes for your spoken proposal, then organise your writing into short paragraphs.

Read an example recommendation after trying the task

I recommend allowing phones in class only when they serve a clear learning purpose. Keeping them in bags at other times could help students concentrate without losing the benefits of digital tools.

One advantage of phones is that they give learners quick access to dictionaries and information. Some students also depend on assistive tools to take part in lessons. A complete ban could therefore create unnecessary barriers for these learners.

However, notifications and messages can interrupt concentration. To reduce this risk, teachers could explain when devices are needed and ask students to silence unrelated notifications. Learners who need ongoing access should agree suitable arrangements with the teacher.

I suggest testing this approach for four weeks. During the trial, teachers could record how often phone use interrupts activities and collect short student reflections. The school could then compare these observations with those from previous lessons. Although this would not prove that phones improve learning, it could help the school make a more informed decision.

Notice: the answer gives a position, recognises an opposing concern, proposes a safeguard and explains a review process. Your recommendation can differ if you support it clearly.

5. Check your progress

I can acknowledge another viewpoint. I can support a recommendation and suggest a way to evaluate it.

Mark each goal: not yet / with help / independently. Write one thing to practise next.

Answer key & teaching notes

Possible revisions: 1. Unstructured phone use can distract some learners. 2. Some learners benefit from phone-based tools. Accept alternatives that preserve meaning and avoid unsupported absolutes.

Support: “Although…, I suggest… because…” Stretch: distinguish an anecdote from representative evidence.

For open tasks, check completion, clarity, appropriate language and progress towards the goal. Model answers are examples; other well-supported answers are welcome.

Original practice material prepared for this resource library. Suggested CEFR levels and ages are guidance, not placement results. Use independently, with a partner or with a teacher. To save offline, use your browser’s Save page option. For a PDF, select Print / save as PDF.